In a recent report, Kerrisdale Capital has taken a strong stance against the overvaluation of MicroStrategy’s shares. They argue that the premium at which the shares are trading, representing over two and a half times the spot price of Bitcoin, is unwarranted. According to Kerrisdale Capital, for MicroStrategy’s shares to be justified at their current price, Bitcoin would need to be trading at an exorbitant $177,000. This discrepancy has led the company to take a bearish position on MicroStrategy, viewing it as a proxy for Bitcoin that does not align with the digital asset’s true value.
Despite the recent decline in MicroStrategy’s shares following Kerrisdale Capital’s report, the firm believes that there is an opportunity for a pair trade. They predict that the inflated premium on MicroStrategy’s shares will likely decrease in the future, creating a potential opening for investors. Kerrisdale Capital clarifies that their analysis is not driven by a negative outlook on Bitcoin or MicroStrategy individually but rather by the distorted relationship between the two entities.
Delving deeper into MicroStrategy’s operations, Kerrisdale Capital highlights that the company’s software analytics division contributes only 3% to its overall value. Much of MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin acquisitions have been financed through debt and equity offerings, leading to dilution in shareholder value. Despite an increase in Bitcoin holdings, Kerrisdale notes that the amount of BTC per share has remained relatively stagnant over the years. These factors call into question the rationale behind MicroStrategy’s current premium valuation.
While some argue in favor of MicroStrategy’s premium due to factors like reinvestment of software business cash flows and ease of trading, Kerrisdale Capital remains unconvinced. MicroStrategy’s current 2.6x equity premium to Bitcoin far exceeds the historical average of 1.3x, signaling a potential overvaluation. The company points out that this premium has only been surpassed on a small percentage of trading days since 2021, reinforcing their belief in the discrepancy.
In light of the evolving landscape of cryptocurrency investment, with increased accessibility and low-cost options, MicroStrategy’s appeal as a primary Bitcoin investment route has diminished. CEO Michael Saylor’s confidence in the company’s unique value proposition and its positioning as a major holder of Bitcoin may face challenges in the face of changing market dynamics. While Saylor touts MicroStrategy’s leverage offerings and lack of fees as advantages over traditional ETFs, the company’s premium valuation remains a key point of contention. As MicroStrategy aims to accumulate more BTC and expand its presence in the Bitcoin ecosystem, managing capital and operations effectively will be crucial for its long-term success.
Leave a Reply